How to choose between two job offers

January 31, 2022

Having two jobs to choose from sounds like an ideal scenario for a job seeker, doesn’t it? However, this can be more challenging than you think. Before you dive into analysing each job offer, think about what is important to you at this point in your career. Perhaps you’re looking to work from home, or you want a more flexible work schedule. Perhaps more money is important to you right now. Maybe cultural fit is your greatest priority. Whatever your goals, reflect on what you want out of your working life.


Confirm the details

The first thing to do is confirm the details of each job offer and make sure you get them in writing. This should include things like salary and any benefits, work hours, terms of your employment, start date, probation periods etc.



List and rank what’s important

A great way to work out what’s essential to you in a job is to make a list and rank the elements from most important to least important. We have provided a table so you can do a super-quick analysis of your next job offer. Give each element a score from 1-5 stars. This makes it easier to directly compare one job offer to another.

Download table in PDF

A note about location

Many candidates don’t realise how important location is to their fit for a role. With so many people re-evaluating what is important to them during the pandemic, how much time is spent commuting to work and the flexibility to work from home has become more important than ever. So consider location seriously before accepting a role, especially if it involves a longer commute than you are used to.


Salary comes second to security and work/life balance

At a time when uncertainty has been consistent, it’s no wonder job security has become the most important consideration for jobseekers when appraising a potential employer. SEEK research shows that due to COVID-19, 2 out of 3 candidates would trade a higher salary for job security if faced with that decision. It’s clear that candidates are also choosing work/life balance over salary. Where does salary rank for you in the job evaluation ranking table?



Summary

When a candidate receives a job offer, they try to visualise their future in that organisation. Our advice when receiving multiple offers is to be clear about each potential employers’ value proposition. What can the organisation offer you in terms of flexible work arrangements? Do they have a great company culture and social events in place? Do they use up to date technology and have sound systems and procedures in place? Discuss the job offer with friends and family. Peer feedback is always a great way to consider a variety of viewpoints.

By Corrin Corrin July 29, 2025
Your questions in an interview say as much about you as your answers. Edge's Mary-Jane Massicci shares what types of questions can get noticed by hiring managers.
By Corrin Corrin July 22, 2025
Backed by insights from our 2025 Employment and Salary Trends Report, we unpack the current salary landscape across property and real estate roles in SA.
By Corrin Corrin July 21, 2025
Edge Recruitment has once again been named Best Recruitment Agency in Real Estate and Property in SA, at the 2025 Sourcr Awards – for the fourth consecutive year!
By Corrin Corrin July 7, 2025
What matters more — qualifications or experience? We explore the balance between these two factors and what today’s property job market in SA really demands.
By Corrin Corrin July 7, 2025
A new report reveals a growing disconnect between what employers think their staff want—and what employees actually value when it comes to workplace benefits.
By Corrin Corrin July 1, 2025
For employers and candidates, the FY25 hiring landscape presents a mix of opportunity and challenge — and demand is rising across the industry.
By Corrin Corrin June 24, 2025
The end of the financial year is a busy time across South Australia’s property and real estate industry — not just for accountants and agencies reviewing the books, but also for professionals reassessing their career direction. Whether you’re in sales, property management, leasing, or support, July often marks a fresh start . And if you've been considering a career move, there are some compelling reasons why right now might be the best time to take action . 1. New Budgets Mean New Hires At the start of a new financial year, most property and real estate businesses reset their annual budgets. That means: New headcount is approved Growth targets are locked in Teams that were stretched thin during the past year are finally given the green light to hire For job seekers, this creates a surge in demand for talent — particularly for roles in sales, business development, and property management where revenue growth is key. Agencies are also more likely to invest in onboarding, training, and marketing new staff now, rather than mid-year or during the Christmas slowdown. 2. Performance Reviews Are a Catalyst for Change EOFY is traditionally when many employees receive formal performance reviews and commission payouts. While positive reviews can lead to promotions or salary increases, for others, this period can shine a spotlight on: Unmet expectations Lack of progression opportunities Underappreciation or under-compensation If you’ve walked away from your review feeling deflated, that’s a clear sign it may be time to explore new opportunities — particularly if your current role no longer aligns with your long-term goals. 3. The Spring Property Market Is Coming — Get In Early We all know that spring is one of the busiest times of year for the property market, and smart candidates position themselves well in advance. If you start your job search in July: You have time to transition into a new role You can complete onboarding and training You’ll be ready to hit the ground running when market activity spikes in September Waiting until spring often means you’ll be competing with more candidates for fewer roles, with less lead-in time to settle into your new environment. 4. Candidate Supply Is Still Tight — Leverage That Advantage Across South Australia, we’re still seeing a shortage of experienced candidates in many parts of the property and real estate industry. Sales agents, property managers, and leasing consultants with proven track records are in high demand — and employers are increasingly willing to offer: Competitive salary and commission structures Flexible working arrangements Stronger professional development pathways If you’ve got the experience and drive, now is the time to negotiate from a position of strength. 5. Clarity and Momentum Matter There’s something about July that naturally invites people to reset. The first half of the year is behind you, and there’s still time to make big career moves before the year is out. Whether you’ve outgrown your current role, want to break into a new segment of the industry, or are just feeling burnt out — making a change now can give you the clarity and momentum you need. HOT TIP: Don’t Wait for “The Perfect Time” Many people stay in roles longer than they should because they’re waiting for the “right moment.” But as with most facets of the property and real estate industry — timing is everything . With budgets resetting, hiring activity on the rise, and the spring market just around the corner, EOFY is the window of opportunity you’ve been waiting for. Ready to Make Your Move? Edge Recruitment specialises in connecting property and real estate professionals with the right roles across South Australia. Whether you're actively job hunting or just want to explore what’s out there, our team is here to help. Get in touch for a confidential chat — your next role could be just around the corner.
By Corrin Corrin June 17, 2025
Each year, we ask employees what matters most. The 2025 data shows priorities continue to evolve. For employers, the message is clear: it’s not just about offering more—it’s about offering what matters most.
By Corrin Corrin June 5, 2025
New data from people2people recruitment shows younger Australians don't believe they'll ever retire. We break down what this research means for property professionals in SA.
By Corrin Corrin June 5, 2025
In a recent live stream conversation, Peta Seaman and Deanne Goodwin, a senior property professional shared the current trends shaping the property recruitment landscape in 2025.