6 Reasons You Lost Candidates In the Hiring Process

November 23, 2023

What drives away talent through the hiring process? Whilst the chronic candidate shortage has eased slightly, we’re still in a tight employment market where job seekers have plenty of choice. In this competitive space, employers need to have smart recruitment strategies in place to successfully attract high-quality talent. These are the most common mistakes employers make that can cause candidates to go elsewhere.

  • Failing to act swiftly
    Time is of the essence, especially in a competitive job market. Candidates often have multiple offers on the table, and a slow hiring process can be a deal-breaker. If the competition is moving swiftly, providing a clear timeline from application to offer, it’s likely to sway candidates in their direction. Our recommendation for employers is to streamline their hiring process. This includes prompt feedback, efficient scheduling of interviews, and a transparent communication channel.

  • Not offering remote work options or flexibility
    Remote work has become a desirable option for many professionals. Offering the option to work remotely or a hybrid model (for jobs where it is feasible), can give employers a significant advantage over the competition. By crafting workplace policies that allow for flexibility and a healthy work-life balance, employers can position themselves as attractive and desirable places to work.

  • Below-par salary and benefits
    In a market where talent is at a premium, compensation is a crucial factor. If the competitor is offering a more competitive salary or an attractive benefits package, it can be a significant pull. Employers need to align their compensation and benefits with industry standards to remain competitive. Seeking data-driven insights and salary benchmarks can be instrumental in making competitive offers.

  • Poor Communication
    Trust is a two-way street. If a candidate perceives that the competition communicates more transparently and honestly about the role, expectations, and company direction, it can be a decisive factor. Job seekers value openness and clarity throughout the hiring process.

  • Not showcasing company culture
    One crucial aspect that often tilts the scales is company culture. Candidates are not just seeking a job; they are looking for an environment where they can thrive. If the competitor showcases a vibrant and inclusive culture, with employee testimonials and a transparent look into daily operations, it looks like an appealing prospect. Employers can showcase their unique culture through social media, job ads, employee spotlights, and engaging content on their career pages.

By recognizing the changing expectations of job seekers and addressing their needs, smart businesses can position themselves as attractive and desirable workplaces and succeed in the hiring stakes.

       — Jane Carey, CEO at Edge Recruitment

Through addressing factors such as the speed of the hiring process, competitive compensation and communication, employers can enhance their recruitment strategies. In doing so, they not only attract top talent but also retain a competitive edge in the ongoing fight for skilled professionals.

By Corrin Corrin September 9, 2025
Learn how to identify and manage psychosocial hazards, to support employee wellbeing, boost performance, and create a healthier, safer work culture.
By Corrin Corrin September 1, 2025
In a recent episode of The Property Edge live market update, we unpacked what’s happening in the South Australian property job market for employers and job seekers.
Job seeker and recruiter having an online interview
By Corrin Corrin August 18, 2025
We're seeing an increase in job seekers who say they want a new job, but stall when it comes to being flexible, responsive, or open to exploring opportunities.
By Corrin Corrin August 4, 2025
In a recent episode of The Property Edge, we gained some first-hand insights into what makes recruitment in the property sector so uniquely challenging in South Australia in 2025.
By Corrin Corrin July 29, 2025
Your questions in an interview say as much about you as your answers. Edge's Mary-Jane Massicci shares what types of questions can get noticed by hiring managers.
By Corrin Corrin July 22, 2025
Backed by insights from our 2025 Employment and Salary Trends Report, we unpack the current salary landscape across property and real estate roles in SA.
By Corrin Corrin July 21, 2025
Edge Recruitment has once again been named Best Recruitment Agency in Real Estate and Property in SA, at the 2025 Sourcr Awards – for the fourth consecutive year!
By Corrin Corrin July 7, 2025
What matters more — qualifications or experience? We explore the balance between these two factors and what today’s property job market in SA really demands.
By Corrin Corrin July 7, 2025
A new report reveals a growing disconnect between what employers think their staff want—and what employees actually value when it comes to workplace benefits.
By Corrin Corrin July 1, 2025
For employers and candidates, the FY25 hiring landscape presents a mix of opportunity and challenge — and demand is rising across the industry.