How to Choose the Right Person Every Time: A Proactive Guide for Employers

May 8, 2025

Hiring the right team member can feel like striking gold—especially in South Australia's fast-paced property industry. But too often, employers face frustrating setbacks:

  • Candidates who nail the interview but don’t deliver on the job.
  • New hires who walk away within six months, taking your training investment with them.
  • Disruptive additions who upset team dynamics and morale.
  • Employees who stray from their core responsibilities, chasing tasks outside their scope.


Sound familiar? If so, you’re not alone.


But here’s the good news: there are practical strategies you can implement to reduce these pain points and increase your odds of hiring the right person—every time.


1. Go Beyond the Interview

It’s easy to get swept away by a candidate with polished answers and a charismatic presence. But performance in an interview doesn’t always translate into performance on the job.


Pro tip: Use situational or task-based assessments. Ask candidates to complete a short project or role-play a real-world scenario they’d likely face in the job. This gives you a preview of how they think, communicate, and handle pressure—beyond just words.


Also, reference checks are a crucial part of the process and shouldn’t be treated as just a formality. At Edge Recruitment, all our candidates are thoroughly vetted through reference checks, and we ask specific, pointed questions to gauge real-life experience and performance:


  • “Can you describe a time they were under pressure in a role?”
  • “Would you rehire them, and why or why not?”
  • “How did they interact with colleagues or clients?”


2. Hire for Culture and Competence

A great candidate isn't just skilled—they also need to fit into your existing team culture. A misaligned hire can quickly create tension and reduce productivity across the board.


Pro tip: Introduce key team members into the later stage of your hiring process. Let candidates meet their potential colleagues informally. Observe how they interact and ask your team for their impressions afterward.


When we interview candidates, we always include values-based questions in interviews to gain insights into how well they will fit in with your current culture:


  • “What work environment helps you thrive?”
  • “Tell me about a time you clashed with a colleague—how did you resolve it?


3. Define the Role Razor-Clearly

One of the most common issues in recruitment is mismatched expectations. If a candidate doesn’t fully understand what’s expected—or if the role keeps evolving without clarity—they may drift or lose interest.


Pro tip: Provide a detailed job description and stick to it. During interviews, paint a realistic picture of what day-to-day life looks like in the role. Be transparent about challenges as well as perks.


And set boundaries early. If someone’s veering off track and taking on tasks outside their role, have a proactive conversation to bring the focus back.


4. Create a Stellar Onboarding Experience

The first 90 days are crucial. It’s where expectations are set, relationships are built, and loyalty is won—or lost.

Pro tip: Structure your onboarding process. Have a clear plan that includes:


  • A welcome session with team introductions
  • Clear training objectives and timelines
  • Weekly check-ins for the first month
  • An open-door policy for feedback and questions


The better the onboarding, the more likely your new hire is to succeed and stick around.


5. Work With a Specialist Recruitment Partner

Let’s be honest: finding the right candidate is time-consuming. And when it goes wrong, the costs—both financial and cultural—are high.


That’s where we come in. At Edge Recruitment, we specialise in matching high-performing professionals with top-tier roles in South Australia's property industry. We understand the nuances of the market, and we know how to screen not just for skill—but for staying power and cultural fit.


In Summary

To avoid common hiring pitfalls:


  • Don’t rely on interviews alone—test real-world skills
  • Hire for cultural fit as well as capability
  • Set clear job expectations from day one
  • Make onboarding a priority
  • Partner with experts who understand your industry


Choosing the right person every time isn’t a pipe dream—it’s a process. And with the right strategies (and support), it’s absolutely achievable.

By Corrin Corrin May 12, 2025
If your recruitment process is slow, unclear, or overly complicated, you could be handing great talent to your competitors. So how can you streamline your process without sacrificing quality?
By Corrin Corrin April 28, 2025
We know what you’re thinking…“Shouldn’t I sell myself as much as I can in an interview?” Yes. But here’s the catch: you should sell your authentic self—not an exaggerated version of you.
By Corrin Corrin April 22, 2025
We break down what a recent ‘Evolving Working Life’ report by SEEK means for the property industry in South Australia, and what job seekers and employers can do to stay ahead.
By Corrin Corrin April 8, 2025
Now in its 20th year, Edge Recruitment's annual women in property event attracts professionals from all areas of the property industry whilst raising funds for the Cancer Council SA.
By Corrin Corrin April 7, 2025
Peta Seaman, Managing Director of Edge Recruitment, sat down with Emma Slape, CEO of Turner Real Estate to discuss the current challenges and opportunities of recruiting in the South Australian real estate industry.
By Corrin Corrin April 7, 2025
Which property roles are causing employers to jump through hoops to recruit in the current employment market in South Australia?
By Corrin Corrin March 12, 2025
In the competitive world of recruitment, understanding why top performers stay in their roles is crucial. We take a look at what drives the long-term commitment of talented people.
By Corrin Corrin February 25, 2025
In the latest edition of Edge Recruitment’s The Property Edge market update, Peta Seaman, Managing Director and Mary-Jane Massicci, Senior Recruitment Consultant, explored the real-life experiences of working parents and shared insights into how employers can better support their staff.
A group of people are sitting around a table looking at papers.
By Corrin Corrin February 10, 2025
For many job seekers, having a job application rejected is just part of the process of job hunting. However, it may be your resume that is unknowingly turning off recruiters and employers. As a recruiter, your resume is our first impression of you, so your success in the job market relies heavily on getting this important document right. A well-structured and succinct CV should not only demonstrate your skills and experience clearly and succinctly, but also acts as a marketing tool, promoting your personal brand to prospective employers. Here are the most common resume mistakes we have seen by job seekers – so you can avoid making them too! Applying for roles you are not experienced or qualified for This is our number one reason for dismissing a job application. If this occurs, you have clearly not read the job description thoroughly. For example. your application will be turned away if you are a real estate receptionist with two years’ experience applying for a senior property management role requiring five plus years’ experience. Inconsistent or vague dates You may be surprised how often we see vague, missing or inconsistent dates of employment on resumes, which can look like you are trying to hide something. For example, ‘2012-2014’ could mean you have been in that role for as little as 12.5 months or a maximum of three years – a large disparity. So, when listing your previous jobs – especially if you have been in a role for less than 5 years – provide the year and the month for both start and completion dates. Missing dates Not explaining any absences or gaps in your employment timeline only leaves it up to the recruiter or employers’ imagination. Make sure you address gaps such as travel, study, parental leave, redundancy, surgery, or temp/freelance work, also providing the year and the month for the start and end of these periods. Misleading information Recruiters use several methods to authenticate the information given on resumes. So, providing false or misleading information will be detrimental to your chances of getting the job. For example, if your resume does not match the information provided on your LinkedIn profile, this is an immediate red flag for recruiters. Spelling & grammar errors It is amazing how many resumes we receive with typos and grammar mistakes in them. One typo could be forgiven if the rest of your application is great but resumes containing multiple spelling errors and poor grammar will be rejected. We recommend you read and re-read your resume and get a friend to check it and provide some feedback. Submitting a resume with errors is a waste of both your time and the recruiters, so do not rush it! Stretching the truth Alarm bells ring when we see candidates stretching the truth on their resume. It causes us to consider what other key details may have been embellished or left out. For example, when a candidate indicates they have three years of experience in property management on their resume and we find out in an interview that it is more like 18 months. So keep it truthful! Extra-long resumes Recruiters and employees see a lot of CVs, so resumes that are 10 pages long simply may not get read word for word and may reduce the effectiveness of your application. We estimate that only 50% of the resumes that we see hit the mark and concisely convey the information needed to progress in the application process. A concise resume of two to three pages is the ideal length, which clearly outlines your education, job history, skills and contact details in an easy-to-read format. No achievements, just skills Many people only list day-to-day duties they did in previous jobs, rather than describing their achievements in those roles. As much as you can, showcase the impact you had in previous roles rather than just tasks undertaken, with results/outcomes quantified with numbers, percentages, or specific outcomes. For example, instead of saying “managed a team,” say “managed a team of 10, increasing productivity by 20% within six months.” Too many buzzwords We see many ten-dollar words used when a five-dollar word will work perfectly. Write your resume in clear, understandable language. For example, don't feel the need to say "utilise" instead of "use" or load up your resume with buzzwords like "proactive" and "synergy" unless they're the only words that will express your thought. Recruiters and hiring managers need to skim your resume in a few seconds to find out what you do, not spend hours reading it like it was a detective novel, trying to piece together the clues. Remember - keep your resume brief, simple and easy to understand, and impress with your achievements, not with your fancy language. This is how you'll get the interview, and then your dream job.
A group of people are sitting in chairs waiting for a job interview.
By Corrin Corrin February 4, 2025
These insider tips from Edge Recruitment’s experienced recruiters are worth their weight in gold to help you nail the job search process! Recruiters/employers may look at your social media profile Both recruiters and employers can view publicly accessible information to help decide if a candidate would make a good cultural fit for their organisation. Have you considered how your past online activity could be viewed by potential employers? Do you know what images, posts and comments are publicly available? Have you Googled yourself recently? Make sure the content and photos on your Facebook, LinkedIn or Instagram profiles are appropriate for future employers. Interview no-shows can affect your chances of getting future jobs Ghosting or having a poor excuse for not showing up to your interview with your recruiter can crush your chances of winning future roles. Whilst legitimate excuses are fine, not attending your interview – especially after you have confirmed your attendance - demonstrates a lack of reliability and indicates that you may not be relied upon to show up for future interviews, let alone be at work on time. We recommend thinking twice before not attending an interview without letting your recruiter know in advance. Not all jobs are advertised Up to 80% of our jobs at Edge Recruitment are filled via networking and database searches, even before we have ever advertised it. Therefore, it really pays to register with us as soon as you are ready to start your job hunt. If you are registered with us and we have a job that suits your skills and experience, you may get a call from our consultants without even applying for the role. Your resume IS make or break Certain elements on a resume can detract from your professional image or lower your chances of even being considered by a recruiter or hiring manager, so make sure you get it right from the outset. Firstly, carefully read a job description and ensure you meet the core requirements to prevent applying for jobs that you are unqualified for. Next, do some research to learn about the company’s values, culture, and mission to determine if it is a good fit for you. Next, customise your resume and cover letter for that job to highlight relevant skills and experiences that align with the job description. Lucky for you, Edge has you well covered in the resume department. Read these 10 resume hacks and avoid these 15 things , and you can’t go wrong. A job interview may be just around the corner Be prepared that you may need to attend an interview sooner than you think. Recruitment periods vary wildly from employer to employer, so smarten your wardrobe if it is needed and get a haircut if it’s looking neglected. Whilst most job searches take a while, sometimes job offers can result from the very first interview. Read Edge Recruitment’s comprehensive interview guide to ace every step of the interview process. Be prepared to answer questions about salary Whilst it is unlikely you will be asked about salary in a first interview with an employer, a first meet or phone call with a recruiter will include a discussion about salary expectations. So, it pays to be prepared. We highly recommend that you do some salary research and consider what your expectations are before applying for jobs. For more advice and support for your job search, reach out to the experienced Edge Recruitment team today who are ready to help you land your dream job.
More Posts